Ontario – S. 11 ICCA allows one Court review of tribunal’s negative jurisdiction determination – #966

In Grace v. United Mexican States, 2026 ONCA 700, the Court dealt with an application to quash an appeal of the Superior Court’s decision to set aside the Tribunal’s Award. The Tribunal had proceeded through the full arbitration process to the hearing and issued a final Award deciding only that it lacked jurisdiction over the matter. The appellant claimed that it was entitled to appeal the Superior Court’s decision because the Tribunal had completed the arbitration process and issued an “Award”, thereby triggering recourse under Article 34 of the UNCITRAL Model Law (the “Model Law”). The respondent brought the application to quash the appeal on the basis that section 11 of Ontario’s International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 (the “ICAA”) permits a party to apply to the Superior Court to “decide the matter” where a Tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction pursuant to Article 16(2) of the Model Law but bars any appeal of this Superior Court decision. The Court’s analysis turned on the matters the Tribunal had decided in the Award, rather than the label given to the decision. It held that, even though the Tribunal’s decision was identified as an “Award”, it addressed only threshold jurisdictional issues (without dealing with the merits, liability or damages) and was therefore equivalent to a ruling on jurisdiction as a preliminary question. The Court found that the Tribunal’s “Award” was no different than a decision that declined jurisdiction as a preliminary question. Therefore, it quashed the appeal.

Background – The dispute involved a group of investors (the “Investors”) in Oro Negro, a Mexican offshore oil-rig company. The Investors alleged that Mexico had engaged in a politically- motivated campaign that drove the company out of business. In 2018, the Investors commenced an Arbitration against Mexico under Chapter 11 of the North American Free Trade Agreement (“NAFTA”). The Arbitration was seated in Toronto and administered by the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (“ICSID”) pursuant to the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules bearing ICSID Case No. ARB UNCT/18/4 (the “Arbitration”).

In August 2024, after approximately four years of proceedings that included 31 procedural orders, the filing of all the parties’ evidence, and the conduct of a hearing with 13 witnesses, the Tribunal issued an Award concluding that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the claims (the “Award”). The Award did not evaluate the substantive claims or determine liability or damage issues.

The Superior Court’s decision – With Toronto as the place of arbitration, the Ontario Courts maintained supervisory jurisdiction, governed by the ICAA, which incorporates the Model Law.

Pursuant to section 11(1) of the ICAA, if a tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction, any party may apply to the Ontario Superior Court to decide the matter.

Section 11 of the ICAA provides as follows:

“(1) If, pursuant to article 16(2) of the Model Law, an arbitral tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction, any party may apply to the Superior Court of Justice to decide the matter.

(2) The court’s decision under subsection (1) is not subject to appeal.”

An award may also be set aside by the Court for jurisdictional reasons under Article 34(2) of the Model Law.

The Investors applied to the Ontario Superior Court to decide the matter of the Tribunal’s ruling that it did not have jurisdiction pursuant to section 11 of the ICAA and to set aside the Award under Article 34 of the Model Law. 

The Investor’s application challenged the Tribunal’s Award in the Ontario Superior Court on two principal grounds.

The first ground it argued was that the Tribunal had misunderstood its jurisdiction. The Tribunal concluded that: (i) certain claimants held both American and Mexican nationality and could not bring the claims against Mexico in the circumstances; and (ii) the remaining Investors’ claims involved indirect losses that were not recoverable under the applicable NAFTA provisions.

The second ground was an alleged reasonable apprehension of bias. One of the Arbitrators had accepted a separate engagement as counsel in another arbitration involving substantially similar legal issues while the Oro Negro arbitration was ongoing. The engagement was not disclosed to the parties. The Investors argued that this created a reasonable apprehension of bias and undermined the integrity of the Arbitration.

In April 2026, the Ontario Superior Court agreed with the Investors that the Tribunal erred in determining that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the claims and set aside the arbitral Award in Grace et al. v. United Mexican States, 2026 ONSC 2104.

The Ontario Court of Appeal decision – Mexico was dissatisfied with the Superior Court’s decision and appealed to the Ontario Court of Appeal. In response, the Investors brought a motion to quash the appeal pursuant to section 11(2) of the ICAA.

Section 11(1) provides that where an arbitral tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction, any party may apply to the Superior Court to decide the matter; however, section 11(2) states that the court’s decision is expressly not subject to appeal.

Mexico asserted that section 11 was not applicable as the Tribunal had issued a final Award. According to Mexico, the only recourse for the Investors to challenge the Award was pursuant to Article 34 of the Model Law, which would permit an appeal from the Superior Court’s decision. 

The Investors argued that Mexico had no right to appeal in the first place because of the statutory bar in section 11.

The dispute in the Ontario Court of Appeal turned on the “form” of the Tribunal decision. Mexico claimed that the form of the Tribunal’s decision—a final Award—was determinative. The Investors argued that the substance of the Tribunal’s decision—purely on jurisdiction—fell within the appeal prohibition in section 11.

The Ontario Court of Appeal sided with the Investors and quashed Mexico’s appeal. The Court reasoned that the Tribunal’s Award dealt exclusively with jurisdictional issues. It had not determined whether Mexico was liable, whether the Investors had suffered compensable damages, or the substantive merits of the Investors’ claims. Therefore, despite being called a final Award, the Court held that the Tribunal’s decision was effectively equivalent to a preliminary ruling on jurisdiction.

The Court found the language of section 11 to be clear. No appeal lies from a decision of the Superior Court of Justice on a jurisdictional matter – whether the Tribunal has ruled that it does or does not have jurisdiction – and this is not altered by the Model Law.  The Court further stated that the decision not to bifurcate the proceedings and address the jurisdictional argument separately does not preclude the operation of section 11.

The Court declined to address the arbitrator bias issue because the Appeal had already been quashed and doing so would have no practical effect on the parties.

Commentary:

While not addressed in the fairly short Court of Appeal decision, the interplay between the relevant specific Model Law provisions and their relationship to section 11 of the ICAA is an interesting discussion.

Article 16(3) of the Model Law deals with a tribunal ruling on a jurisdictional plea. It states that a tribunal can make such a ruling either as a preliminary question or in an award on the merits. It also permits recourse to the courts in a very narrow situation that—only where the tribunal rules as a preliminary question that it has jurisdiction, can a party go to a court “to decide the matter”, “which decision shall be subject to no appeal”.  There is no provision in Article 16 that permits a party to have a court decide the matter (i) where the Tribunal rules it does not have jurisdiction, or (ii) where the jurisdiction ruling is made in an award. Commentary in UNCITRAL’s 2012 Digest of Case Law on the Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration, at page 89, states that this exclusion was intentional, as a ruling by the arbitral tribunal that it lacked jurisdiction was final with regards to the proceedings and it was inappropriate to compel arbitrators who had made such a ruling to continue the proceedings.

In 2014, the Uniform Law Conference of Canada (the “ULCC”) issued a Report of the Working Group on New Uniform Arbitration Legislation (the “ULCC Report”). The ULCC Report at paras 92-95 identified that Article 16(3) is silent on whether a party can go to court in the situation where a tribunal rules that it lacks jurisdiction (negative ruling).  This was identified as a gap that ought to be closed and the ULCC Report recommended the addition of a provision in the New Uniform ICAA to allow the court to determine the matter in the case of a negative jurisdiction ruling.  The suggested wording was intended to track that of Article 16(3) and matches that in section 11 of the ICAA. 

However, the wording of Article 16(3) also limits the ability to seek court review only where the tribunal makes a ruling on jurisdiction as a preliminary question. This portion of text is not tracked in section 11 of the ICAA. It is unclear if the absence of the “preliminary” condition was intentional or seen as irrelevant. However, the appellant in the case at issue argued that it was important that the Tribunal made a ruling on jurisdiction as a preliminary question, which permitted court intervention. One wonders what comes next for the parties as a result of the Ontario Court of Appeal decision: can the Tribunal be compelled to reconsider its Award?  Continue to hear the Arbitration?

What we do know is that arguably the most important takeaway from this case is that calling something a final award does not necessarily make it reviewable by a court. The Court looked beyond the terminology used by the Tribunal and examined what the Award actually determined. For arbitration practitioners, this means that the legal consequences of an award depend on its substance rather than its title.

This decision is also noteworthy for any international commercial and investment treaty arbitration seated in Ontario. An Ontario statutory seemingly technical procedural provision can determine the outcome of a major international arbitration dispute. Mexico did not ultimately lose its appeal because the Court of Appeal reconsidered the Tribunal’s jurisdictional analysis or the alleged arbitrator bias. It lost its appeal because the Court concluded that the Ontario legislature had already removed the right to appeal that jurisdictional determination.

For counsel, the case is a reminder that the right to challenge an arbitral award and the right to appeal a court’s decision concerning that award are two distinct questions. Specifically, section 11 creates significant finality.  You may only get one opportunity to challenge jurisdiction in court.

If a party challenges an arbitral jurisdictional decision before the Ontario Superior Court, it should not assume that it can subsequently appeal an unfavourable decision. The Superior Court application must be prepared as a potentially final determination of the jurisdictional issue.