In Grace v. United Mexican States, 2026 ONCA 700, the Court dealt with an application to quash an appeal of the Superior Court’s decision to set aside the Tribunal’s Award. The Tribunal had proceeded through the full arbitration process to the hearing and issued a final Award deciding only that it lacked jurisdiction over the matter. The appellant claimed that it was entitled to appeal the Superior Court’s decision because the Tribunal had completed the arbitration process and issued an “Award”, thereby triggering recourse under Article 34 of the UNCITRAL Model Law (the “Model Law”). The respondent brought the application to quash the appeal on the basis that section 11 of Ontario’s International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 (the “ICAA”) permits a party to apply to the Superior Court to “decide the matter” where a Tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction pursuant to Article 16(2) of the Model Law but bars any appeal of this Superior Court decision. The Court’s analysis turned on the matters the Tribunal had decided in the Award, rather than the label given to the decision. It held that, even though the Tribunal’s decision was identified as an “Award”, it addressed only threshold jurisdictional issues (without dealing with the merits, liability or damages) and was therefore equivalent to a ruling on jurisdiction as a preliminary question. The Court found that the Tribunal’s “Award” was no different than a decision that declined jurisdiction as a preliminary question. Therefore, it quashed the appeal.
Continue reading “Ontario – S. 11 ICCA allows one Court review of tribunal’s negative jurisdiction determination – #966”Ontario – Arbitrator removed mid-hearing for cross-examining witnesses, despite parties’ agreement to inquisitorial approach – #965
In Atkinsréalis Construction (Pacific) Inc. v. GIP Construction Ontario East Ltd., 2026 ONSC 5666(“Atkinsréalis”), the Court removed a sole arbitrator part-way through an arbitration pursuant to s. 13(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17 (the “Act”). The Court held that the arbitrator, by conducting prepared, cross-examinations of the applicant’s witnesses, had “descended into the arena” and created circumstances that may give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The Court reached this conclusion even though both parties had agreed that the arbitrator could adopt a “somewhat more inquisitorial approach” and could “question any witness.” In doing so, the Court emphasized that the duties of equal and fair treatment in s. 19 of the Act are mandatory, and that parties cannot contract out of the requirement that an arbitrator be, and be seen to be, neutral.
Continue reading “Ontario – Arbitrator removed mid-hearing for cross-examining witnesses, despite parties’ agreement to inquisitorial approach – #965”Québec – Public order “outcome” test applies to enforcement of foreign awards – #964
In TCA Global Credit Master Fund c. Apelian, 2025 QCCA 1083, the Québec Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court’s refusal to recognize and enforce a Florida judgment against three Québec-domiciled guarantors. The Court of Appeal concluded that a foreign judgment in favour of a creditor, which gives effect to an advance waiver of fraud, is inconsistent with public order as understood in international relations. The Florida court had dismissed the guarantors’ defence of fraudulent misrepresentation on the basis that they had signed waiver and release clauses in the loan and guarantee agreements. The Court of Appeal made three holdings. First, in considering the public order issue, the “outcome” of a foreign decision under sec. 3155(5) CCQ must be assessed according to its concrete effects, not solely the reasons for the decision. Second, “public order as understood in international relations” is a subcategory of Québec public order, so its content does not need to be proven. Third, a decision giving effect to an advance waiver of the sanctions for fraud is manifestly inconsistent with that public order. The Court’s treatment of the “outcome” test and of the content of international public order is of interest to practitioners facing public order objections at the recognition and enforcement stage, including for arbitral awards whose homologation may likewise be refused on public order grounds (art. 652 C.C.P.; New York Convention, art. V(2)(b)). Although this case concerns a foreign judgment rather than an arbitral award, its analysis of the “outcome” test may inform public order review of foreign awards, an issue Québec courts have rarely examined in depth.
Continue reading “Québec – Public order “outcome” test applies to enforcement of foreign awards – #964”Alberta – Can an Alberta judge order a substitute arbitrator on remittal? – #963
In Frederico v Cabral, 2026 ABCA 251 (CanLII) a single judge of the Court of Appeal granted Federico’s application for permission to appeal a King’s Bench decision (the “Decision”) that set aside a spousal support Arbitration Award (the “Award”) and ordered a new hearing before a substitute arbitrator. The judge found that Federico had raised a reasonably arguable position: that the appointment of a substitute arbitrator exceeded the authority of the King’s Bench judge who heard the original appeal from the Award. Section 16(1) of Alberta’s Arbitration Act(the “Act”) provides that a substitute arbitrator shall only be appointed when an arbitrator’s mandate is terminated. Pursuant to section 14, an arbitrator’s mandate ends only under specific enumerated circumstances. None of them applied here. Despite this, the appeal judge appointed a substitute arbitrator on remittal. The case raises an important question: does an arbitrator’s mandate automatically end at delivery of a final award in Alberta? It also highlights whether a court can interfere with parties’ intention to have their dispute determined by a specific arbitrator by ordering a substitute arbitrator.
Continue reading “Alberta – Can an Alberta judge order a substitute arbitrator on remittal? – #963”Manitoba – Inconsistent, contradictory, and flawed arbitration agreements cannot be performed – #962
In Bains v Loader, 2026 MBCA 66, the Court found no palpable and overriding error in the lower court’s judgment that ICC arbitration agreements in two international commercial contracts were incapable of being performed because of poor drafting. However, the Court reversed the findings that two technical prerequisites of the Peace River Hydro v Petrowest Corp. stay test were not satisfied, and declined to endorse the findings that the agreements were null and void or inoperative, “or any suggestion … that exceptions, other than those set out in the ICAA, are relevant to the exception analysis in this case.”
Continue reading “Manitoba – Inconsistent, contradictory, and flawed arbitration agreements cannot be performed – #962”Alberta – Competence-competence and efficiency considered in declaration of invalidity of arbitration application – #961
In Fraser N Peterson Professional Corporation v Mark WM Leishman Professional Corporation, 2026 ABKB 568, the Court dismissed an application under section 47 of the Alberta Arbitration Act, RSA 2000, c A-43 (the “Act”) for a declaration that an arbitration agreement was invalid, and that the arbitrator lacked jurisdiction. Although the competence-competence principle would ordinarily require the arbitrator to decide the jurisdiction question first, the Court held that it could hear the jurisdictional challenge under section 47 of the Act. The Court relied on foundational efficiency principles, noting that the parties had advanced comprehensive submissions on an uncontested factual record, the dispute turned primarily on the interpretation of written agreements, and the statutory framework prevented the applicant from making the same challenge before the arbitrator. The Court concluded that the arbitration agreement was valid and survived the termination of the parties’ underlying contract.
Continue reading “Alberta – Competence-competence and efficiency considered in declaration of invalidity of arbitration application – #961”Ontario – Shareholder of corporate signatory is party to partnership arbitration clause – #960
In 1171757 Ontario Limited et al. v 1171758 Ontario Limited et al., 2026 ONSC 4414, the court held that the shareholder of a corporate partner qualified as a “party” to the partnership agreement and therefore was entitled to bring claims pursuant to its arbitration clause. Applying principles of contractual interpretation, the court found that the plain wording of the partnership agreement contemplated that the term “parties”, which appeared in the agreement’s arbitration clause but was not a defined term in the agreement, included shareholders of the partners. Further, the court determined that claims brought by “parties” respecting contracts made with the corporation which legally owned the partnership’s property assets were arbitrable under the partnership agreement, despite that the corporation itself seemingly was not a party to the agreement.
Continue reading “Ontario – Shareholder of corporate signatory is party to partnership arbitration clause – #960”Ontario – Non-signatory “arguably” bound by arbitration clause signed by affiliate – #959
In Bombardier Inc. v. Alstom Rail Sweden AB, 2026 ONCA 528, the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed an appeal from an order staying an Ontario action in favour of ICC arbitration. The Court held that the motion judge did not err in finding it arguable that a non-signatory affiliate could avail itself of an arbitration clause in an agreement it did not sign. Since Canadian case law on non-signatory issues is thinner than elsewhere, this case is an important one to consider.
Continue reading “Ontario – Non-signatory “arguably” bound by arbitration clause signed by affiliate – #959”Alberta – Court application aimed at arbitrator to stay arbitration pending appeal denied – #958
In Carrigan v Withers, 2026 ABCA 58, the Court denied an application for a stay of arbitration and enforcement proceedings pending an appeal on the ground that it did not have the legislative authority to do so. The application raised issues of irregularities in the formation of the arbitration agreement. Of significance to this case summary, the applicant named the arbitrator as well as the opposite party in the arbitration as respondents.
Continue reading “Alberta – Court application aimed at arbitrator to stay arbitration pending appeal denied – #958”Alberta – Court Dismisses Application to Decide Scope of Unwritten Arbitration Agreement – #957
In 1775773 Alberta Ltd. v Hill, 2026 ABKB 511, the Application Judge considered the limits of the Court’s jurisdiction to determine the scope of an arbitration. The case arose in circumstances where the parties had agreed that all but one of the issues between them would be arbitrated but had not entered into a written arbitration submission agreement or otherwise consented to the Court determining whether the remaining issue should be referred to arbitration. The Application Judge refused to refer any of the issues to arbitration, finding that there was no “meeting of the minds” on the submission agreement and that an arbitration agreement could not be implied from the parties’ Unanimous Shareholders Agreement (the “USA”). He also found that he lacked authority to refer the disputed issue to arbitration because the parties had not consented to the Court determining whether it should be arbitrated.
Continue reading “Alberta – Court Dismisses Application to Decide Scope of Unwritten Arbitration Agreement – #957”