Ontario – S. 11 ICCA allows one Court review of tribunal’s negative jurisdiction determination – #966

In Grace v. United Mexican States, 2026 ONCA 700, the Court dealt with an application to quash an appeal of the Superior Court’s decision to set aside the Tribunal’s Award. The Tribunal had proceeded through the full arbitration process to the hearing and issued a final Award deciding only that it lacked jurisdiction over the matter. The appellant claimed that it was entitled to appeal the Superior Court’s decision because the Tribunal had completed the arbitration process and issued an “Award”, thereby triggering recourse under Article 34 of the UNCITRAL Model Law (the “Model Law”). The respondent brought the application to quash the appeal on the basis that section 11 of Ontario’s International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 (the “ICAA”) permits a party to apply to the Superior Court to “decide the matter” where a Tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction pursuant to Article 16(2) of the Model Law but bars any appeal of this Superior Court decision. The Court’s analysis turned on the matters the Tribunal had decided in the Award, rather than the label given to the decision. It held that, even though the Tribunal’s decision was identified as an “Award”, it addressed only threshold jurisdictional issues (without dealing with the merits, liability or damages) and was therefore equivalent to a ruling on jurisdiction as a preliminary question. The Court found that the Tribunal’s “Award” was no different than a decision that declined jurisdiction as a preliminary question. Therefore, it quashed the appeal.

Continue reading “Ontario – S. 11 ICCA allows one Court review of tribunal’s negative jurisdiction determination – #966”

Ontario – Counsel disqualified in action and arbitration over access to privileged documents in arbitration – #949

In Specialty Life Inc. v. Daumier Financial Services Inc., 2026 ONSC 1869, the Court ordered the disqualification of plaintiffs’ counsel because it had requested, received, and reviewed some of the defendants’ privileged documents as counsel for the plaintiffs in a related arbitration, albeit for a legitimate purpose in that arbitration. The Court found that there were no steps, short of disqualifying plaintiffs’ counsel in both the action and the arbitration that would “avoid the mischief resulting from use of the [defendants’] privileged information”.

Continue reading “Ontario – Counsel disqualified in action and arbitration over access to privileged documents in arbitration – #949”