In Grace v. United Mexican States, 2026 ONCA 700, the Court dealt with an application to quash an appeal of the Superior Court’s decision to set aside the Tribunal’s Award. The Tribunal had proceeded through the full arbitration process to the hearing and issued a final Award deciding only that it lacked jurisdiction over the matter. The appellant claimed that it was entitled to appeal the Superior Court’s decision because the Tribunal had completed the arbitration process and issued an “Award”, thereby triggering recourse under Article 34 of the UNCITRAL Model Law (the “Model Law”). The respondent brought the application to quash the appeal on the basis that section 11 of Ontario’s International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 (the “ICAA”) permits a party to apply to the Superior Court to “decide the matter” where a Tribunal rules on a plea that it does not have jurisdiction pursuant to Article 16(2) of the Model Law but bars any appeal of this Superior Court decision. The Court’s analysis turned on the matters the Tribunal had decided in the Award, rather than the label given to the decision. It held that, even though the Tribunal’s decision was identified as an “Award”, it addressed only threshold jurisdictional issues (without dealing with the merits, liability or damages) and was therefore equivalent to a ruling on jurisdiction as a preliminary question. The Court found that the Tribunal’s “Award” was no different than a decision that declined jurisdiction as a preliminary question. Therefore, it quashed the appeal.
Continue reading “Ontario – S. 11 ICCA allows one Court review of tribunal’s negative jurisdiction determination – #966”Ontario – Arbitrator removed mid-hearing for cross-examining witnesses, despite parties’ agreement to inquisitorial approach – #965
In Atkinsréalis Construction (Pacific) Inc. v. GIP Construction Ontario East Ltd., 2026 ONSC 5666(“Atkinsréalis”), the Court removed a sole arbitrator part-way through an arbitration pursuant to s. 13(6) of the Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17 (the “Act”). The Court held that the arbitrator, by conducting prepared, cross-examinations of the applicant’s witnesses, had “descended into the arena” and created circumstances that may give rise to a reasonable apprehension of bias. The Court reached this conclusion even though both parties had agreed that the arbitrator could adopt a “somewhat more inquisitorial approach” and could “question any witness.” In doing so, the Court emphasized that the duties of equal and fair treatment in s. 19 of the Act are mandatory, and that parties cannot contract out of the requirement that an arbitrator be, and be seen to be, neutral.
Continue reading “Ontario – Arbitrator removed mid-hearing for cross-examining witnesses, despite parties’ agreement to inquisitorial approach – #965”Ontario – Non-signatory “arguably” bound by arbitration clause signed by affiliate – #959
In Bombardier Inc. v. Alstom Rail Sweden AB, 2026 ONCA 528, the Court of Appeal for Ontario dismissed an appeal from an order staying an Ontario action in favour of ICC arbitration. The Court held that the motion judge did not err in finding it arguable that a non-signatory affiliate could avail itself of an arbitration clause in an agreement it did not sign. Since Canadian case law on non-signatory issues is thinner than elsewhere, this case is an important one to consider.
Continue reading “Ontario – Non-signatory “arguably” bound by arbitration clause signed by affiliate – #959”Ontario – JAMS arbitration clause survives bias and unconscionability challenges – #954
Abouzeid v. eXp Realty of Canada Inc et al., 2026 ONSC 3329 confirms that speculative concerns regarding institutional bias in the administration of an arbitration, absent evidence of actual unfairness or an inability to appoint an independent and unbiased arbitrator, will not render an arbitration agreement invalid, unconscionable, or incapable of performance, and will not prevent a mandatory stay under s. 7(1) of Ontario’s Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c. 17 (the “Arbitration Act”). The Court rejected the plaintiff’s two principal arguments: first, that the administering authority under the relevant arbitration agreement (JAMS) would be unable to administer an unbiased arbitration because the respondent frequently selected JAMS as an administering institution; and second, that the limited size of the Canadian JAMS arbitrator roster rendered the arbitration agreement incapable of performance (an issue for Canadian administering institutions to consider). These arguments failed because the parties were free to select any arbitrator – they were not restricted to the JAMS roster – and because repeat use of an administering authority does not give rise to bias.
Continue reading “Ontario – JAMS arbitration clause survives bias and unconscionability challenges – #954”Ontario – Award enforced despite parties’ agreed institution and applicable rules changed – #953
InFrontier AF LP v. Rahmani, 2026 ONCA 289, was an appeal from an order enforcing an arbitral award made in Dubai. The primary issue was whether the application judge erred in considering the law of Dubai (the seat) in considering whether the arbitral procedure accorded with the parties’ agreement after the arbitration proceeded under a different institution and Rules regime than the ones specified in the parties’ agreement. The application judge found that the parties had agreed to procedural Rules that contemplated an amendment and that the new Rules were an amendment of the Rules specified by the parties in their agreement. The Court dismissed the appeal and accorded the application judge significant deference, finding that there was no extricable legal error in his interpretation of the parties’ agreed procedure.
Continue reading “Ontario – Award enforced despite parties’ agreed institution and applicable rules changed – #953”Ontario – Counsel disqualified in action and arbitration over access to privileged documents in arbitration – #949
In Specialty Life Inc. v. Daumier Financial Services Inc., 2026 ONSC 1869, the Court ordered the disqualification of plaintiffs’ counsel because it had requested, received, and reviewed some of the defendants’ privileged documents as counsel for the plaintiffs in a related arbitration, albeit for a legitimate purpose in that arbitration. The Court found that there were no steps, short of disqualifying plaintiffs’ counsel in both the action and the arbitration that would “avoid the mischief resulting from use of the [defendants’] privileged information”.
Continue reading “Ontario – Counsel disqualified in action and arbitration over access to privileged documents in arbitration – #949”Ontario – Aroma Round 2: no set-aside where procedural breach on non-material issue – #945
In Aroma Franchise Company, Inc. et al v. Aroma Espresso Bar Canada Inc. et al, 2026 ONSC 768, the Court dismissed a second application to set aside two arbitral awards in the “Aroma saga”, this time on various grounds pursuant to Article 34 of the Model Law (procedural breach relating to inability to present one’s case on an issue, jurisdiction, and sufficiency of reasons – the ground relating to jurisdiction was straightforward and is not addressed in this case summary). Although the Court found that the Applicants were unable to present their case on one issue (whether one individual was a proper party to the arbitration), such that Article 34(2)(ii) of the Model Law was met, it concluded that this issue was superfluous and accordingly did not exercise its discretion to set aside the award because the issue was not material.
Continue reading “Ontario – Aroma Round 2: no set-aside where procedural breach on non-material issue – #945”Ontario – Parties must pay arbitrator as part of good faith contractual performance – #937
In Ongko (Boswell) v. Ongko, 2025 ONSC 7235, the applicant was precluded from bringing her set-aside application. She was not only time-barred from doing so because she commenced the application after the statutory 30-day period, but the Court also held that it lacked jurisdiction to set aside an award and to remove an arbitrator for bias where a party fails to comply with the arbitrator challenge requirements of the Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17 and the terms of their arbitration agreement, which provided for a mandatory challenge process if either party had concerns about the arbitrator’s neutrality. The applicant elected not to proceed with the challenge before the arbitrator after she refused to pay the arbitrator’s fees. She then chose not to participate in the arbitration. The Court made clear that parties must continue to pay the arbitrator’s fees to complete the contractually agreed dispute resolution process. It also found that there was also no procedural unfairness stemming from her own choices.
Continue reading “Ontario – Parties must pay arbitrator as part of good faith contractual performance – #937”Ontario – Anti-suit injunction granted restraining foreign arbitration by affiliate – #935
In Lochan v Binance Holdings Limited, 2025 ONSC 6493, the Court granted an anti-suit injunction that prevents Binance Holdings Limited (“Binance”) and affiliates from pursuing arbitration in Hong Kong against the representative plaintiffs in a certified class action in Ontario. The Court determined that Binance was using an affiliated entity, Nest Services Limited (“Nest”), as an alter ego to bypass previous Ontario rulings that found the arbitration clause in its contract with members of the class to be unconscionable and void.
Continue reading “Ontario – Anti-suit injunction granted restraining foreign arbitration by affiliate – #935”Ontario – Set Aside not available for bespoke process – #923
In Tehama Group Inc. v. Pythian Services Inc, 2025 ONSC 4134, the Court denied an application to set aside an international award on the basis of alleged procedural flaws in an accounting arbitration to resolve a dispute about whether a purchase price adjustment payment was owing to the seller of a business. The Court reviewed the terms of the parties’ bespoke arbitration agreement and the arbitral award and concluded that the specialist arbitrator, an accounting firm, had followed the summary dispute resolution process to which the parties had agreed. The Court ruled there was no breach of natural justice. Instead, the parties got the process they bargained for: “determinations strictly from a financial accounting perspective” and not “legal guidance or opinion [or] legal interpretation.”
Continue reading “Ontario – Set Aside not available for bespoke process – #923”