In Cruickshank Construction Ltd. v The Corporation of the City of Kingston, 2022 ONSC 5704, Justice Myers allowed an application to appoint an arbitrator, providing his views on the method for that appointment. He also dismissed the Respondent’s cross-application for a declaration that the notice of arbitration was limitation-barred and that the Applicant had not complied with preconditions to arbitration in the parties’ agreement. Justice Myers held that there was no basis in the Ontario Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17 (“Arbitration Act”) to permit the court to grant the cross-application and the grounds raised were not matters of arbitral jurisdiction.
Continue reading “Ontario – Limitations defence not a matter of arbitral jurisdiction – #674”Ontario – Does an appeal of a costs award require leave? – #672
In Schickedanz v Wagema Holdings Ltd., 2022 ONSC 5315, Justice Ramsay dismissed the motion by Wagema Holdings Ltd (Respondent on appeal) to quash Appellant Schickedanz’s appeal of a costs award. Wagema argued that leave was required under s. 133(b) of the Ontario Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43 (“CJA”) and so the appeal was also out of time. Justice Ramsay was not persuaded that Wagema would prevail when the issue was determined by the appeal judge. First, the parties’ arbitration agreement contained a broad appeal process, without a leave requirement for costs appeals. Second, there is nothing in s. 45 of the Ontario Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c. 17 that requires leave to appeal a costs award or imports the leave requirement set out in the general costs appeal provision in s. 113(b) of the CJA. Third, the parties could contract out of the appeal provisions in s. 45 of the Arbitration Act pursuant to s. 3. Imposing a leave requirement to appeal a costs award would amount to judicial interference with the parties’ right to contract, which was recognized by the Supreme Court of Canada in TELUS Communications Inc. v. Wellman, 2019 SCC 19. Ultimately, it would be up to the judge hearing the appeal to decide whether leave was required and, if so, whether the appeal was out of time and whether the appeal had merit.
Continue reading “Ontario – Does an appeal of a costs award require leave? – #672”Ontario – No oral hearing required even if one party requests it – #667
Optiva Inc. v Tbaytel, 2022 ONCA 646, raises two issues of interest to arbitration law. First, the Appellant (Optiva) made a jurisdictional objection to the arbitrator’s ruling allowing the Respondent (Tbaytel) to bring a motion for summary judgment. The arbitrator then issued a procedural order in which he ruled that he had jurisdiction. After hearing the motion, the arbitrator issued a partial award on the merits, which was in favour of Tbaytel. Optiva applied to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice to “decide the matter” of the arbitrator’s jurisdiction and to set aside the partial award, both pursuant to s.17 (rulings and objections re jurisdiction) of the Ontario Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c. 17 (the “Act”). However, the application judge found that Optiva had failed to bring its application on time and dismissed it. Pursuant to s. 17(8), it was required to do so within 30 days of the arbitrator’s jurisdiction ruling, not after the issuance of the partial award on the merits. The Ontario Court of Appeal agreed with the application judge and dismissed Optiva’s appeal, but for different reasons. The application judge erred in finding that Optiva was out of time to ask the Court to “decide the matter” because the preliminary ruling was not jurisdictional. Relying upon Inforica Inc. v. CGI Information Systems and Management Consultants Inc., 2009 ONCA 642, the ruling that the matter could proceed by summary judgment was procedural, not a ruling on the arbitrator’s “own jurisdiction”; therefore, s. 17 was not engaged. However, the appeal was dismissed because the arbitrator was entitled to decide matters of procedure, both under the Act and under the parties’ arbitration agreement, and did so. Second, the Court of Appeal held that s. 26(1) of the Act does not require an oral evidentiary hearing, even if one party requests it.
Continue reading “Ontario – No oral hearing required even if one party requests it – #667”Ontario – No appeal lies from preliminary jurisdictional decision – #666
In Iris Technologies Inc. v. Rogers Communications Canada Inc., 2022 ONCA 634, the Ontario Court of Appeal quashed a motion for leave to appeal from the lower court’s decision in which it was asked to “decide the matter” of arbitral jurisdiction under the Ontario Arbitration Act, 1991. The Court of Appeal confirmed its earlier decision, United Mexican States v. Burr, 2021 ONCA 64, made under the Ontario International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017. The Court also made it clear that no appeal lies from lower court decisions which “decide the matter” of arbitral jurisdiction when the question comes before the court as a preliminary issue before the final award is rendered.
Continue reading “Ontario – No appeal lies from preliminary jurisdictional decision – #666”Ontario – Action abuse of process – even against new defendant – where issues already arbitrated – #661
In Doria v Warner Bros. Entertainment Canada Inc. et al., 2022 ONSC 4454, Justice Koehnen granted the Defendants’ motion to strike the Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim pursuant to Rule 21.1(3)(d) of the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure, R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 194 on the ground that it was an abuse of process because it sought to relitigate issues that were previously decided by an arbitrator. The Plaintiff argued that s. 139 of the Ontario Courts of Justice Act. R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, allowed him to bring a subsequent proceeding for the same or similar relief against a person who was jointly liable and who was not bound by a previous judgment. Justice Koehnen found that s. 139 did not apply these circumstances, where the Plaintiff had a full opportunity to have his entire claim adjudicated in the arbitration, was awarded judgment, and had fully collected on the judgment. The Plaintiff’s complaint was that the arbitrator did not grant him his full damages. The fact that the Defendants were not parties to the arbitration and therefore not bound by the award was irrelevant.
Continue reading “Ontario – Action abuse of process – even against new defendant – where issues already arbitrated – #661”Ontario – Court of Appeal upholds “single proceeding” insolvency model over recourse to arbitration – #660
In Mundo Media Ltd. (Re), 2022 ONCA 607, Court of Appeal for Ontario Justice Julie Thorburn dismissed a motion for leave to appeal a decision denying a motion to stay a receiver’s court proceeding. The Appellant/Moving Party sought the stay on the basis of an international arbitration agreement. Justice Thorburn found no reversible error in the motion judge’s choice to apply the “single proceeding model”, applicable in insolvency proceedings, with the effect that the Appellant/Moving Party, one of the insolvent company’s debtors, could not require the receiver to arbitrate its claim rather than litigate it. Together with the Superior Court’s decision below, this decision provides important guidance on the interplay between arbitration agreements and claims advanced in the bankruptcy and insolvency context.
Continue reading “Ontario – Court of Appeal upholds “single proceeding” insolvency model over recourse to arbitration – #660”Ontario – Arbitrator to determine jurisdiction/validity of arbitration clause in employment dispute – #654
In Irwin v. Protiviti, 2022 ONCA 533, the Ontario Court of Appeal confirmed that, unless the question is one of pure law or is a question of mixed fact and law requiring only a superficial review of the evidence, questions about the jurisdiction of an arbitrator are to be arbitrated. This includes whether an arbitration clause in an arbitration contract is void for unconscionability, or for inconsistency with the Employment Standards Act, 2000, S. O. 2000, c. 41 (“ESA”) or the Human Rights Code, R.S.O. 1990, c. H. 19 (“the Code”).
Continue reading “Ontario – Arbitrator to determine jurisdiction/validity of arbitration clause in employment dispute – #654”Ontario – Failure to pay award does not justify security for costs – #653
In Amelin Resources, Inc. v. Victory Energy Operations LLC, 2022 ONSC 4514, Associate Justice C. Wiebe dismissed a motion for security for costs under Rule 56.01(1)(d) of the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure, finding that Victory, the Defendant/Moving Party, did not meet its onus of showing that there was “good reason to believe” that Amelin, the Plaintiff/Responding Party, had insufficient assets to pay the Victory’s costs in Ontario. Amelin’s failure to pay amounts granted to Victory under an arbitration award and U.S. Court order did not suffice.
Continue reading “Ontario – Failure to pay award does not justify security for costs – #653”Ontario – Arbitrator resignation did not terminate arbitration – #652
In Kubecka v Novakovic, 2022 ONSC 4503, Justice Pinto determined that, on the wording of the parties’ arbitration agreement, the parties had agreed that the arbitration was not terminated and their dispute returned to the jurisdiction of the courts – even when the arbitrator resigned. He appointed a replacement arbitrator on the application of one of the parties.
Continue reading “Ontario – Arbitrator resignation did not terminate arbitration – #652”Ontario – Stay Granted where Competing Arguable Interpretations of Scope of Arbitration Agreement – #648
In Biancucci v Buttarazzi, 2022 ONSC 4054, Justice Myers followed the analytical framework for a stay application under s. 7 of the Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c. 17 (the “Act”) as set out in Haas v. Gunasekaram, 2016 ONCA 744. The arbitration agreement at issue was contained in a settlement agreement, and interconnected litigation and arbitration taking place over a decade made analysis of the scope of the arbitration agreement complex. Ultimately, Justice Myers confirmed that there were competing arguable interpretations of scope and granted the stay, leaving jurisdiction to be ultimately determined by the arbitral panel.
Continue reading “Ontario – Stay Granted where Competing Arguable Interpretations of Scope of Arbitration Agreement – #648”