Ontario – no appeal from Master’s order to stay litigation in favour of arbitration – #468

In Wang v. Mattamy Corporation, 2021 ONSC 2635, Ontario’s Divisional Court in brief reasons refused to vary or set aside a judge’s decision in Wang v. Mattamy Corporation, 2020 ONSC 7012 to dismiss an appeal from a Master’s order granting a stay of their litigation in favour of arbitration. In determining that Applicants had failed to demonstrate an error of law or palpable and overriding error of fact, the Court agreed that section 7(6) of Ontario’s Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17 is “a complete bar to the appeal” which provides that is no appeal from a decision of the court staying an action on the basis of an arbitration clause. For an opposite result in first instance on an appeal of a Master’s decision based on interpretation/application of Alberta rules of court and legislation, see the Arbitration Matters note “Alberta – court rules permitting appeal of Master’s stay decision consistent with section 7(6) of Arbitration Act – #412” regarding Agrium, Inc v. Colt Engineering Corporation, 2020 ABQB 807.

Continue reading “Ontario – no appeal from Master’s order to stay litigation in favour of arbitration – #468”

Ontario – court invokes kompetenz-kompetenz to refuse stay of ongoing arbitration pending appeal/set aside – #464

In Kingston Automation Technology Inc. v. Montebello Packaging, 2021 ONSC 2684, Mr. Justice Graeme Mew dismissed an application to stay an award pending other applications to appeal that award and to set it aside.  Addressing one of applicant’s grounds which raised a jurisdictional issue involving whether all claims granted were within the scope of the agreement to arbitrate.  Mew J. noted that the applicant now objecting to those claims being added was the party which had added them.  Mew J. held that applicant had agreed to their inclusion, had not objected within the delays at the onset of the arbitration, only raising the objection “rather late in the game”. Mew J. also refused to order a stay of the arbitration which remained ongoing.  Applicant had made no application to stay to the arbitrator and Mew J. concluded he had no basis on which to intervene.  Mew J. acknowledged the potential for “wasted time and expense” but such could be compensated in an award for costs and “it is not, in any event, a basis for displacing the kompetenz-kompetenz principle by interfering with the arbitrator’s management of the arbitration”.

Continue reading “Ontario – court invokes kompetenz-kompetenz to refuse stay of ongoing arbitration pending appeal/set aside – #464”

Ontario – non-party witnesses applying to arbitrator to quash summonses do not attorn to jurisdiction – #462

Despite extensive rights of appeal provided in BP’s and D’s agreement to arbitrate, Mr. Justice William S. Chalmers in Bergmanis v. Diamond, 2021 ONSC 2375 held that their agreement did not apply to non-party witnesses who successfully applied to the arbitrator under sections 29 and 30 of the Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17 to quash summonses issued by the arbitrator.  Unsatisfied with the arbitrator’s decision to quash summonses, claimant appealed but without seeking leave.  Chalmers J. held that the successful non-parties did not attorn by applying to the arbitrator to quash the summonses and therefor the general provisions for appeal under the legislation applied. Relying Ontario First Nations (2008) Limited Partnership v. Ontario Lottery And Gaming Corporation, 2020 ONSC 1516, Chalmers J. held that Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65 did not modify the standard of review.  Chalmers. J. further held that a legal principle as important a solicitor-client privilege is not a question of legal importance to the legal system as a whole if neither of the parties disputes the legal principle.

Continue reading “Ontario – non-party witnesses applying to arbitrator to quash summonses do not attorn to jurisdiction – #462”

Ontario – jurisdiction involves whether arbitrator has authority to make inquiry, not the answer to the inquiry – #458

In Parc-IX Limited v. The Manufacturer’s Life Insurance Company, 2021 ONSC 1252, Mr. Justice Markus Koehnen distinguished between an objection to jurisdiction and an appeal because one does not agree with answer made within that jurisdiction.  “Jurisdiction is determined not by asking whether the arbitrator made a correct decision but by asking whether the arbitrator had authority to make the inquiry he made”. Koehnen J. recharacterized Applicant’s challenge to the award. “What [Applicant] really complains about here is not the arbitrator’s jurisdiction to make the inquiry but the arbitrator’s answer to the inquiry.  That, however, is beyond the purview of a jurisdictional review”.  Koehnen J. also dismissed Applicant’s attempt to impose an arbitrator’s exercise of discretion in a costs award issued in 1990 on another arbitrator’s exercise of his discretion in 2020. Koehnen J. held that the 1990 determination was based on the exercise of discretion applied to circumstances of that case and it would be an improper exercise of discretion to determine costs in 2020 simply by applying the result arrived at in 1990.  Koehnen J. also noted differing treatments of Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65 but supported applying the correctness standard to a review of an arbitrator’s award for reasons set out at para. 72 of Ontario First Nations (2008) Limited Partnership v. Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation.

Continue reading “Ontario – jurisdiction involves whether arbitrator has authority to make inquiry, not the answer to the inquiry – #458”

Ontario – experienced mediator’s involvement in/support of class proceeding settlement contributes to court approval of settlement – #453

In a class proceeding,  Mr. Justice Benjamin T. Glustein in Kaplan v. PayPal CA Limited, 2021 ONSC 1981 approved a settlement agreement as a “fair and reasonable and in the best interests of the Class Members”, noting that the settlement had been achieved by involving “a senior and highly-regarded lawyer and mediator” to resolve the claims.  When evaluating the proposed settlement against the criteria set out in Robinson v. Medtronic, Inc., 2020 ONSC 1688, Glustein J. supported his own approval of the settlement terms with inter alia references to the terms being recommended and supported by the experienced mediator.

Continue reading “Ontario – experienced mediator’s involvement in/support of class proceeding settlement contributes to court approval of settlement – #453”

Ontario – Ontario courts’ mandatory mediation “slightly favours Ontario” in forum non conveniens analysis – #452

In Beaule v. Manufacturers Life Insurance Company, 2021 ONSC 1876, Mr. Justice James F. Diamond dismissed defendant’s application to decline jurisdiction on the basis of forum non conveniens.  As part of his analysis of the presumptive connecting factors identified in Club Resorts Ltd. v. Van Breda, 2012 SCC 17 (CanLII), [2012] 1 SCR 572, Diamond J. also considered that Ontario, unlike Québec, imposed mandatory mediation.  Diamond J. determined that depriving plaintiff of the mandatory mediation could quantify as a loss of juridical advantage and “slightly favours Ontario”.

Continue reading “Ontario – Ontario courts’ mandatory mediation “slightly favours Ontario” in forum non conveniens analysis – #452”

Ontario – court urges parties consider mediation/arbitration for “unusual financial transactions” – #450

When imputing income to spouses to determine temporary spousal support, Mr. Justice David A. Jarvis in G. v. S., 2021 ONSC 1625 commented on the complexity of the financial transactions included in the information on which the parties asked him to rely.  After detailing those transactions, which appeared to involve companies owned by the husband or with/by one or more of his family members.  Jarvis J. determined the spousal support and completed his task.  Jarvis J. then closed his reasons by first disclaiming any “proxy” for the Canada Revenue Agency but then observing that “consideration might be given to mediation/arbitration” where there appears to be “unusual financial transactions whether those are family expenses funded through a myriad of related corporate entities … or bundles of “gifted” neatly-bound cash hidden in a bedroom closet in excess of $100,000”.

Continue reading “Ontario – court urges parties consider mediation/arbitration for “unusual financial transactions” – #450”

Ontario – venue change application for arbitrator appointment application an inappropriate, misuse of court resources – read #448

In Toronto District School Board v. Roofmart Ontario Inc., 2021 ONSC 1688, Mr. Justice Frederick L. Myers dismissed R’s application under Rule 13.1.02 of Ontario’s Rules of Civil Procedure, RRO 1990, Reg 194 to change venue from Brampton to Toronto for the adjudication of SB’s application to appoint an arbitrator under section 10 of the Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17.  Though he acknowledged that the parties’ underlying dispute was “wholly Toronto-based”, Myers J. observed that “the question of who arbitrates has no natural connection to any venue”.  Noting that a Brampton-assigned judge had already seized himself of SB’s application to appoint an arbitrator and scheduled an upcoming hearing to decide that application, Myers J. disagreed with R’s attempt to task another judge to hear SB’s application. “Any judge of this court is equally capable of hearing this matter quickly and making a decision on the identity of the arbitrator”.

Continue reading “Ontario – venue change application for arbitrator appointment application an inappropriate, misuse of court resources – read #448”

Ontario – Arbitration Act does not preclude court staying execution of final award under Courts of Justice Act – #444

In Zenith Aluminum Systems Ltd. v. 2335945 Ontario Inc., 2021 ONSC 1128, Mr. Justice Benjamin T. Glustein dismissed attempts to limit the court’s jurisdiction to stay execution of final arbitral awards to only those circumstances set out in section 50(5) Arbitration Act, 1991, SO 1991, c 17. Glustein J. held that section 50(5) does not preclude a stay of execution under section 106 of the Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C. 43.  Glustein J. refused, however, to accept that Rule 20.08 of the Rules of Civil Procedure, RRO 1990, Reg. 194 authorized courts to stay execution of final awards. Glustein J. observed that Rule 20.08 limited its application to summary judgments and, on the record before him, the final awards “are treated as final judgments”, issued by an arbitrator who the parties “asked to conduct the trial” of their dispute.

Continue reading “Ontario – Arbitration Act does not preclude court staying execution of final award under Courts of Justice Act – #444”

Ontario – pre-litigation costs for mediation imposed by legislation recoverable because non-discretionary – #441

In Gelman v. 1529439 Ontario, 2021 ONSC 424, Madam Justice Bernadette Dietrich denied a successful litigant’s claim for pre-litigation costs, following the rule set out in Greenlight Capital, Inc. v. Stronach (2008), 2008 CanLII 34359 (ON SCDC), 91 O.R. (3d) 241 (Div. Ct.).  In doing so, Dietrich J. resurfaced 90 George Street Ltd. v. Ottawa-Carleton Standard, 2015 ONSC 336 in which pre-litigation costs for mediation were awarded in an arbitration and upheld on a post-award challenge.  Those costs related to mediation imposed by the Condominium Act, 1998, SO 1998, c 19 which requires parties to mediate budget disagreements before undertaking arbitration and, as such, did not represent an exercise of discretion by the parties prior to commencing arbitration.

Continue reading “Ontario – pre-litigation costs for mediation imposed by legislation recoverable because non-discretionary – #441”