In TCA Global Credit Master Fund c. Apelian, 2025 QCCA 1083, the Québec Court of Appeal upheld the Superior Court’s refusal to recognize and enforce a Florida judgment against three Québec-domiciled guarantors. The Court of Appeal concluded that a foreign judgment in favour of a creditor, which gives effect to an advance waiver of fraud, is inconsistent with public order as understood in international relations. The Florida court had dismissed the guarantors’ defence of fraudulent misrepresentation on the basis that they had signed waiver and release clauses in the loan and guarantee agreements. The Court of Appeal made three holdings. First, in considering the public order issue, the “outcome” of a foreign decision under sec. 3155(5) CCQ must be assessed according to its concrete effects, not solely the reasons for the decision. Second, “public order as understood in international relations” is a subcategory of Québec public order, so its content does not need to be proven. Third, a decision giving effect to an advance waiver of the sanctions for fraud is manifestly inconsistent with that public order. The Court’s treatment of the “outcome” test and of the content of international public order is of interest to practitioners facing public order objections at the recognition and enforcement stage, including for arbitral awards whose homologation may likewise be refused on public order grounds (art. 652 C.C.P.; New York Convention, art. V(2)(b)). Although this case concerns a foreign judgment rather than an arbitral award, its analysis of the “outcome” test may inform public order review of foreign awards, an issue Québec courts have rarely examined in depth.
Background Facts – In February 2014, TCA Global Credit Master Fund, LP (“TCA”), a Cayman Islands entity, loaned money to Groupe Mercator Transport US, Inc. (“GMT”), the US subsidiary of a Québec transportation and logistics company. The three respondents, all domiciled in Québec, guaranteed the loan. The contracts were governed by Nevada law and contained forum selection clauses in favour of the Florida courts.
After GMT defaulted, TCA first sued the guarantors in Québec in 2017. They successfully argued that the forum selection clauses conferred exclusive jurisdiction on the Florida courts (2017 QCCS 4146 and 2018 QCCA 1132).
The Florida action – In January 2019, TCA sued GMT and the guarantors in Florida. The guarantors filed a defence and cross-application alleging that their consent had been vitiated by TCA’s fraudulent misrepresentations. On January 5, 2021, the Florida court granted TCA’s motion for summary dismissal of the guarantors’ defence. It held that the guarantors had signed a valid waiver of defenses clause, which stated the following:
“13.4 Waiver of defenses. The credit parties and the individual guarantors waive every present and future defense, cause of action, counterclaim or setoff […]. the credit parties and the individual guarantors waive any implied covenant of good faith […].”
A review application was dismissed. Judgments establishing TCA’s right to repayment and quantifying the amounts owed followed. The guarantors’ appeal was dismissed, and the judgments became final.
The Québec application for recognition and enforcement – In March 2023, TCA applied to the Québec Superior Court for recognition and enforcement of the Florida judgment. Mr. Apelian, the only respondent to participate, contested the application under art. 3155(3) and (5) CCQ. He argued that the waiver clause was contrary to public order because it excluded in advance the duty to act in good faith and any cause of action, including one based on fraud. Therefore, the outcome of the Florida judgment was manifestly inconsistent with public order as understood in international relations.
The Superior Court dismissed TCA’s application (2023 QCCS 4924). It found that the Florida judgment did more than require the guarantors to repay a defaulted loan. Its effect was to allow enforcement of a contract whose formation could not be challenged even on grounds of fraud or bad faith – even though the waiver itself may have been obtained through that fraud. The Court held that outcome to be manifestly inconsistent with public order as understood in international relations.
The Court of Appeal Decision – The Court of Appeal dismissed TCA’s appeal on three main grounds:
(1) The “outcome” of a foreign decision is assessed by its concrete effects – The Court agreed with TCA that sec. 3155(5) and 3158 CCQ limit the analysis to the outcome of the foreign judgment and prohibit a review of its merits. It nonetheless rejected TCA’s “overly narrow” view that the outcome was simply an order to pay money under an ordinary secured loan. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Superior Court judge that although the outcome of the judgment appeared, on its face, to be a mere monetary condemnation, its concrete effect was to give effect to a clause waiving the right to invoke fraud. On that view, sec. 3155(5) CCQ could never apply to a judgment enforcing a loan on discriminatory terms or ordering payment of fees under a contract with an unlawful purpose. Although the public order exception to the enforcement of a judgment must be strictly applied, its scope must not be narrowed to the point of compromising its role as a check against serious injustice. The Court held:
“For the purposes of the application of the public order exception, the outcome of a foreign judgment cannot be analyzed solely on the content of its conclusions. Rather, its concrete effects, assessed according to the circumstances of the case, must be considered.” (para. 32)
The Superior Court was therefore right to characterize the outcome as giving effect to a party’s waiver of any cause of nullity, including fraud.
(2) Public order as understood in international relations is part of Québec law and need not be proven – TCA argued that the Superior Court judge had applied the public order exception without any evidence of the values underpinning the international legal order. The Court found this argument rested on a mistaken premise. Following R.S. v. P.R., 2019 SCC 49, ”public order” consists of norms reflecting the moral, social, economic or political conceptions underpinning Québec’s legal order. The Court rejected that argument:
“[T]he public order referred to in art. 3155(5) CCQ is not an actual international public order composed of norms that reflect principles and values universally recognized as fundamental. It is instead a subcategory of Quebec public order […].” (para. 39)
Judicial notice must therefore be taken of public order under sec. 2807 CCQ. Mr. Apelian’s failure to adduce evidence of its content was no bar to applying the exception.
(3) An advance waiver of the sanctions for fraud offends public order as understood in international relations – The Court first confirmed that such a clause is contrary to Québec domestic public order. Fraud necessarily breaches the duty of good faith (sec. 1375 CCQ), and the sanctions in sec. 1407 CCQ cannot be waived in advance. It then held that the rule also applies to legal situations with foreign elements, for three reasons:
- The rule rests on the fundamental principle fraus omnia corrumpit. That principle requires not only that fraud be prohibited but also that it be sanctioned, and a clause allowing a party to benefit from its own fraud runs directly counter to it.
- Civil law and common law systems agree on this solution. The Court added that wide recognition of a mandatory rule in comparative law is a particularly probative indication of its fundamental nature.
- The UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts treat the provisions on fraud as mandatory. Section 3.2.5 states:
“A party may avoid the contract when it has been led to conclude the contract by the other party’s fraudulent representation, including language or practices, or fraudulent non-disclosure of circumstances which, according to reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing, the latter party should have disclosed.
This provision was drafted to meet the needs of international commercial operators justifying its inclusion as principle of public order as understood in international relations.
The Court concluded that the outcome of the judgment was manifestly inconsistent with public order as understood in international relations. It dismissed the appeal. The Florida judgment was not recognized or enforced in Québec.
Commentary:
Although this decision does not directly address arbitration law, it remains highly relevant to arbitration practitioners. Indeed, section 652 CCQ, which deals with the recognition of foreign awards, and section 36(1)(b)(ii) of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law’s Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration (“Model Law”) are provisions similar to section 3155(5) CCQ. Thus, the treatment of the public order issue regarding the recognition of a foreign judgment also applies in arbitration.
Moreover, the treatment of the foreign judgment in this decision is consistent with the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Desputeaux v. Éditions Chouette, 2003 SCC 17, which confirms that the question of compliance with public order is examined in light of the outcome of the decision and not in advance:
“[54] Public order arises primarily when the validity of an arbitration award must be determined. The limits of that concept’s role must be defined correctly, however. First, as we have seen, arbitrators are frequently required to consider questions and statutory provisions that relate to public order in order to resolve the dispute that is before them. Mere consideration of those matters does not mean that the decision may be annulled. Rather, art. 946.5 C.C.P. requires that the award as a whole be examined, to determine the nature of the result. The court must determine whether the decision itself, in its disposition of the case, violates statutory provisions or principles that are matters of public order. In this case, the Code of Civil Procedure is more concerned with whether the disposition of a case, or the solution it applies, meets the relevant criteria than with whether the specific reasons offered for the decision do so. An error in interpreting a mandatory statutory provision would not provide a basis for annulling the award as a violation of public order, unless the outcome of the arbitration was in conflict with the relevant fundamental principles of public order. That approach, which is consistent with the language used in art. 946.5 C.C.P., corresponds to the approach taken in the law of a number of states where arbitration is governed by legal rules analogous to those now found in Quebec law. The courts in those countries have limited the consideration of substantive public order to reviewing the outcome of the award as it relates to public order… And lastly, in considering the validity of the award, the clear rule stated in art. 946.2 C.C.P., which prohibits a court from inquiring into the merits of the dispute, must be followed. In applying a concept as flexible and changeable as public order, these fundamental principles must be adhered to in determining the validity of an arbitration award.”
See also Perreault v. Groupe Jonathan Benoît, 2021 QCCS 1350 (Case note: Québec – breach of public order involves outcome of award, not mistake in application of rules of public order – #466)
This decision also clarifies the burden of proof on the party opposing the recognition of a foreign judgment on the grounds of a violation of public order by stating not only that public order, as understood in the context of international relations, is a matter of judicial notice, but also the scope of the review that must be conducted.
So far, the scope of the review of a foreign award challenged on the grounds of a violation of public order has not been the subject of any substantive analysis in Québec. The Québec Court of Appeal addressed the issue of the recognition of a foreign arbitral award in light of public order as understood in international relations in Smart Systems Technologies Inc. c. Domotique Secant inc., 2008 QCCA 444, but that decision focused on the lack of reasons behind the award rather than on the outcome of the decision itself.
