Julie Hopkins, Author at Arbitration Matters

Meszaros v 464235B.C. Ltd., 2021 BCSC 2021, concerned a petition to have the Court set aside or, alternatively, to grant leave to appeal, two awards related to costs where a party failed to apply within the time limit provided under the previous B.C. Arbitration Act: Arbitration Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 55. The arbitrator had found that the 30-day time limit for seeking costs could be subject to an estoppel that prevented the petitioner from relying on it to challenge the ability of an arbitrator to make an award of costs outside the time limit. Justice D. MacDonald of the British Columbia Supreme Court denied the application to set aside the award but granted leave to appeal on the issue of whether an estoppel could arise on the facts of this case as found by the Arbitrator.

In Ecoasis Resort and Golf LLP v Bear Mountain Resort & Spa Ltd., 2021 BCCA 285, the Applicants (Bear Mountain and related companies) argued on leave to appeal that the arbitrator committed four extricable errors of law relating to whether it was an implied term of a lease that the lessees would have access to limited common property. The Arbitration Act, S.B.C. 2020, c. 2, like the previous Act, allows appeals on questions of law alone provided they satisfy certain other conditions. Two of the alleged extricable legal errors concerned whether the arbitrator implied a term based on a wrong principle; the third concerned whether the arbitrator, in interpreting the lease, allowed the factual matrix to overwhelm the words of the contract; the fourth concerned whether the arbitrator misapplied the law of the duty of good faith by implying a term into the agreement. On examination, Justice Bennett concluded that none of the alleged errors reflected the arbitrator’s reasoning and, further, “all of the so-called legal issues raised by the applicant, fall into the category of mixed fact and law. I do not see any extricable question of law arising from the reasons of the arbitrator” (para. 49). Leave to appeal was denied.

About Arbitration Matters

Arbitration Matters provides brief summaries of recent cases on commercial arbitration issues, as they are released, from across Canada. Therefore, the website is updated frequently. Each Case Note also provides commentary which helps put the case in context. As of Case Note #509 dated July 26, 2021, Lisa C. Munro, has continued the work done by the Honourable Justice Daniel Urbas before his judicial appointment to the Quebec Superior Court. She is assisted by a select group of other experienced arbitration practitioners, who also contribute regularly to the Case Notes.

Author: Julie Hopkins

B.C. – Leave to appeal granted; arbitrator found party’s actions estopped him from raising statutory time limit – #550

B.C. – Leave to appeal denied where alleged legal errors did not reflect arbitrator’s reasoning – #530