Ontario – No appeal where parties agree dispute “finally settled” by arbitration – #737

In Baffinland Iron Mines LP v. Tower-EBC G.P./S.E.N.C., 2023 ONCA 245, Baffinland Iron Mines LP (“BIM”) appealed a decision of Justice Laurence A. Pattillo dismissing its application for leave to appeal an arbitral award. Justice Pattillo had dismissed the application on the basis that the relevant arbitration agreements precluded appeals. BIM then sought to appeal that decision. Tower-EBC G.P./S.E.N.C (“TEBC”) moved to quash the appeal on the basis that there is no right to appeal from a denial of leave to appeal. The Court of Appeal dismissed the application to quash, holding that BIM’s appeal fell within a “narrow category of cases” that are an exception to the rule that there is no right to appeal from a denial of leave to appeal. Those are ones where it is alleged, as here, that the application judge mistakenly declined jurisdiction to consider the leave issues. The appeal itself, however, was also dismissed. The Court of Appeal found that the application judge’s interpretation of the arbitration agreements was correct. The Court concluded, among other things, that in the dispute resolution clause the phrase “finally settled” (used in relation to an arbitration) meant the same as the phrase “final and binding” (used in relation to decisions of a Dispute Arbitration Board, the “DAB”). Both resulted in there being no further recourse from the arbitral award by way of appeal. 

Continue reading “Ontario – No appeal where parties agree dispute “finally settled” by arbitration – #737”